Jane Manning, Author and Illustrator
Philomel Books, Fiction, August 2012
Suitable for: Ages 3 and up
Themes: Feeling left out, Behavior, Self-acceptance, Self-esteem
Opening/Synopsis: “Millie was too short to be tall, too quiet to be loud, and to plain to be fancy. When she spoke at show-and-tell, hardly anyone listened. When she walked into a room hardly anyone looked up.” One day Millie is drawing a flower with chalk on the sidewalk, when three girls from her school walk over her flower until nothing is left but a big smudge. “I’m not a smudge,” she said. Millie is tired of not being noticed and comes up with a plan. She frizzes her hair, sharpens her nails, stomps, and growls. Her behavior becomes obnoxious and wild so people will notice her. She paints the dog’s face blue, scratches the blackboard with her nails, pulls the buds off her neighbor’s flowers, and dumps jelly beans all over the classroom floor. The kids at school notice Millie now, but she doesn’t receive the reaction she hoped for. Millie wishes she were invisible again. Perhaps being fierce isn’t the best way to get noticed.
What I like about this book: You can’t help but love Millie and feel her pain. What child hasn’t felt invisible and left out. No child wants to feel like a smudge. Jane Manning has written a fun and important story about how far a little girl will go to get attention. This is a great lesson that will stay with children for a long time. Being mean doesn’t mean kids will like you. Kids will definitely identify with Millie. Although Millie’s behavior is extreme, it’s a very funny book because of her creative and outrageous character. It also teaches without preaching. Manning’s illustrations are vibrant and colorful and capture Millie’s expressive behavior to a tee. Manning says that “Millie Fierce must have been rattling around inside me for a long time.” “I remember feeling like Millie on many different occasions when I was a kid – like I wasn’t being seen, or heard, or considered.” She has illustrated dozens of books.
Resources: Great discussion book for the classroom. Ask kids if they ever feel like Millie and to share situations when they have felt invisible and left out. Do they feel sad, hurt or mad? How did they handle the situation? What advice would they give Millie? Have kids write a letter to Millie, or draw an exaggerated self-portrait of themselves that shows their sad, angry or wild side.
Every Friday, authors and KidLit bloggers post a favorite picture book. To see a complete listing of all the Perfect Picture Books with resources, please visit author Susanna Leonard Hill’s Perfect Picture Books.
Love this!
LikeLike
Thank you Catherine. I enjoyed this book a lot and kids will certainly identify.
LikeLike
Sounds like a good book to share with children. I remember feeling like a smudge when I was a child, and several times as an adult.
LikeLike
I know I felt like a smudge when I was a child — or back then we said “wall flower.” Great discussion book.
LikeLike
I’d like to read this Pat. I think it is a terrific topic. What happens to Millie? Does she need to be noticed by everyone, or does she just need one special friend? Great PPBF choice!
LikeLike
It is a terrific topic — one we can all identify with. In the beginning she feels totally invisible. She finally has enough and decides that the only way kids will notice her is if she becomes outrageous and fierce, which gets her into trouble at the end. Then she really wishes she was invsible again. There is a satisfying resolution.
LikeLike
Feeling invisible and perceived as a smudge … beautifully written and something I know that kids will connect with … cause I just did. Thanks, Pat!
LikeLike
Barbara, I connected right away. I’ve even had moments as an adult where I’ve felt that way. So it is a good parent/child read. Great for the classroom too.
LikeLike
I LOVE Millie!! That cover is great! I hope that she figures it all out in the end. It’s so hard being a kid sometimes! I’m anxious to check this out and see how it turns out! Thanks for sharing!
LikeLike
You can’t help but love Millie and all of her antics to get noticed. Yes, there is a satisfying ending. Kids will laugh and identify.
LikeLike
What child hasn’t felt invisible? What adult hasn’t felt invisible? These days, only the twenty-somethings seem to get any attention.
LikeLike
I think there are times both children and adults feel invisible, so it is a good discussion book with a child. It’s also very funny, to make the point. Regarding the 20-year-olds, they are in their own zone and desperately trying to be noticed. Can always count on you to add an interesting point.
LikeLike
I think I know Millie! ….I think I know a hundred Millies. I totally agree. This would be a wonderful classroom resource.
LikeLike
Somehow your response ended up in my spam box. Just caught it. I know Millie too and it is a great classroom book. 🙂
LikeLike
This is a universal theme. Many kids now a days do anything to get attention and will identify with this book. Maybe if read as a read aloud book when young they can learn to be good when they are in the difficult teens. Thanks for sharing this improtant book. 🙂
LikeLike
Ha! HA! As Michael Offutt pointed out — look at the 20-year-olds today. On a serious note, kids and adults don’t like to be invisible. Millie is a fun character!
LikeLike
Happy New Year, Pat! What a wonderful story to start PPBF 2013 with! I love the theme..yes, many of us truly understand what it feels like to be ‘invisible’…and kids will love hearing how the mc tried to get attention.:) She is so outrageous that kids will recognize that there are ‘better’ ways to be noticed. A great story to read with a child who is having problems getting attention,
LikeLike
That’s what I like so much about Millie — she is outrageous! So kids will be amused and shocked a the extremes she goes through to get someone to notice her — but as we know there is a message here. Great story for all children — and adults.
LikeLike
Pat…that is a really great point you mention..so many picture books will be helpful for the adult reader as well as the child listener.:)
LikeLike
I felt that way when I read it. I know I have had moments were I walked into a room of people as an adult and felt totally invisible.
LikeLike
This sounds wonderful, Pat, and addresses such an important topic with kids, one we really don’t have well represented on the list so far so I’m really glad you chose this book! Thanks for a great recommendation!
LikeLike
Susanna, I’m happy you enjoyed the selection. This book was very different, but one that children definitely can relate to — even adults. I think we all know what it feels like to be invisible.
LikeLike
I think my class could do with a bit of Millie Fierce. Off to the library I go …
LikeLike
Somehow I missed your commet. I think this is a great book for the classroom! Kids will get the message and love the humor.
LikeLike
Millie reminds me a bit of Mean Jean THE RECESS QUEEN. Have you read that one?
LikeLike
Somehow I missed your comment. No I haven’t read that book. THanks for telling me about it as I will check it out!
LikeLike
I love the opening sentence! You’ve got me hooked again!
LikeLike
Julie, this is such a great book for kids. I couldn’t help but fall in love with Millie — we can all identify with her!
LikeLike
Cute book with a universal message. Love it Pat. I know I quite liked being the quiet invisible one…lol.
LikeLike
I felt more invisible as I reached 5th-6th grades and up. Wasn’t that way as a child. It is a universal message.
LikeLike
What an appealing opening! I must find this one. It sounds great.
LikeLike
Great for the classroom. Haven’t seen anything else like it yet.
LikeLike
Excellent subject; excellent quote from the book that is instantly captivating.
LikeLike
Yes, the author catches your attention immediately with her opening. Thank you for sharing on Twitter.
LikeLike
Sounds like a great book — and I love that opening sentence! Thanks, Pat!
LikeLike
Glad you liked the selection, Beth. Yes, I liked the opening to. Very clever.
LikeLike
What an excellent choice. I love the opening of the book that you quoted – “too short to be tall”… A great message too! 🙂
LikeLike
Glad you enjoyed the book review Erik. She really is an adorable character, even when she’s fierce.
LikeLike
🙂
LikeLike